A European Ghost Town In China?

Recent articles from CNN to the India Times have reported on ghost town cities popping up all over China built in the image of western counterparts. Places like Thames Town outside of Shanghai have been built in the replication of western style cities. Thames town

Thames Town - Complete with British Guards

looks straight out of the United Kingdom (although reports say it was built on an Austrian design aesthetic) complete with churches, town squares and those iconic red telephone booths. An even more interesting point is that Thames town is practically disserted. Most news from China on the real estate market contains statements on how robust and healthy the housing market is, and how Chinese cities are growing at enormous speeds. Areas of Shanghai, Beijing and Hong Kong have real estate prices that rival those of the Western World; so this would appear true. But is China’s real estate bubble about to burst?

Photo credit: Flickr user triplefivechina

Photo credit: Flickr user triplefivechina

Reports and experts state that the Chinese housing market could be over-valued by a whopping  70%, and that millions of new homes go under used and deserted. However I think that this is an overstatement. There are a number of different political and economic mechanisms that are working within China that require the Chinese government to making such an aggressive move towards “oversupplying housing”. The first and most prominent trend today is the massive amount of migration occurring within the nation. Within the next 20 years it is estimated that an additional 200-250 Chinese workers will move to the City from rural areas in search of jobs. This means that China will have to have to create a large amount of cities and housing in an extremely short amount of time. The second trend is an additional 100 million Chinese workers are expected to escalate the capitalistic ladder out of poverty and into middleclass-dom during this time– leaving existing cities with a large amount of demand for better accommodations. The third and most unique factor is how the Chinese government enforces its living and residential permit system known as Hukou (pronounced like who-cow). The Hukou system is a regulatory system that designates where a person/household may reside by geographic area. For instance a farmer from the country side would have to obtain a Hukou city permit in order to legally move into a city to find work. Think of it as a quota immigration system in between two countries, western and eastern China and that will give you some idea of how it works. In an attempt to control migration the Hukou system (while possibly ineffective – just like other quota systems) could be used to steer workers into these smaller newer cities being built and take some of the mass migration pressures away from the larger cities that are overcrowded.

Thames Town Video

Regardless of the current conditions the government has committed itself to creating 20 cities a year for the next 20 years. The strong intervention approach with the housing market and urban growth that the Chinese government has taken is unlike anything the world has ever seen. It will be fascinating to see how it will play out.

-Adam

Shanghai Demolishes Another Urban Village

I discovered last week that an urban village I visited about a year ago in Shanghai is in the process of being demolished.  Although this is all to common in China, this case was especially disheartening because this village housed the architectural studio of YangXu. In the past few years YangXu has developed some innovated designs for integrating the current urban villages into their rapidly urbanization surroundings.

As the names suggests, Urban Villages were once rural villages that have been swallowed by China’s ever expanding cities.  YangXu describes this phenomena:

Driven by the rapid urbanization process in Shanghai, the suburban villages situated in outer-beltways are being swallowed into the “Urban Villages”. The original villagers who lost their fields uncomfortably became the “new citizens”; the defeated villages formed slums, enclosing the city as an “enclave” on the urban periphery. These “Urban Villages” have become a common phenomenon under the process of Chinese urbanization, leading to continual demolition rather than resolution.

Unfortunately demolition seems to be the inevitable fate of so many of these communities in China’s cities.  According to YangXu, his former Urban Village was demolished as part of an “ongoing clearance of the villages” as there are plans to covert the land to  residential and commercial leasehold of properties.  Since the  government of Shanghai, technically owns all of the land, the government certainly stands to profit from such endeavors.  However where the many relocated residents will now live remains unanswered.

YangXu’s design solutions, pictured above, maintain the existing buildings and build new structures on top of them instead of demolishing the existing urban fabric.  Unfortunately though it does not seem likely that these plans will be realized in the near future, as demolition in order to build new towers is certainly more profitable for China’s local governments.

Below is a series of photos of YangXu’s from studio, his work and the urban village that once existed.

- Melissa

Inside YangXu’s studio. More pictures can be found on his website.

YangXu’s pilot project of “Reconstruction and Improvement on Urban Periphery” where he asks:

  1. The original village is endowed with the charm of the traditional framework. Is it possible that these Urban Villages can be preserved and reformed as part of community reconstruction, thereby confronting the demolition of the urbanization process?
  2. Urbanization or modernization should maintain a sense of pluralism, will the reconstruction of “Urban Villages” provide an approach in contrast to the downtown area of Consumerism or Epicurean  
  3. Reconstructions connotes some aspects of “Cultural Self-Consciousness” as part of modernization, can we really reform ourselves through it?

A young resident, standing next to an electrified fence that separates her urban village from the condominium project next door.

Illegal access to electricity and other utilities is very common in this neighborhood.

A neighbor selling fresh meat and fish.

A vegetable vendor.

A house that appears to have been part of the original, rural village.

Photo Credits: Melissa Reese

Urbanization News April 1

This week’s featured story: Construction of NYU Campus in Shanghai Started this week in Pudong The NYU Shanghai project will be China’s first international university co-established with a US university.  NYU president John Sexton officially announced the university early this week right before headlines in China and the US announced that the construction had begun on Monday.  The campus is located in the financial and trade zone of Pudong and it is expected to open in the fall of 2013.  Enrollment is expected to include about 3,000 undergraduate and graduate students from throughout the world, with Chinese students making up more than half. Read more about it in China Daily Newspaper or the the NYU Local

Ashoka: Announces finalist for its Sustainable Urban Housing: Collaborating for Liveable and Inclusive Cities Competition. The three entries that receive the most votes will each earn a prize of US $10,000. Vote now for the three most innovative solutions that “engage communities, entrepreneurs, and key institutions in collaborating to integrate and develop affordable, inclusive, and sustainable urban housing that respects the environment, local cultures, and practices.” Finalist projects are located in India, Brazil, Argentina, Kenya, Mexico, Haiti and the USA.

Did urban planners unwittingly help the Egyptian revolution? “When millions of Egyptian protesters successfully overthrew longtime dictator Hosni Mubarak, observers credited new technology such as Facebook and Twitter as well as the passion and planning of the activists. But some say that decisions made long ago on the design of Cairo played a role… Tali Hatuka, an architect and head of Tel Aviv University’s Laboratory of Contemporary Urban Design, argues that urban planners can help promote democracy by creating formal areas for protests, such as squares or plazas such as Tahrir Square — where Egyptians gathered to protest — and informal areas like parks.” Read more from Congress.org

DfID withdrawal from UN-HABITAT displays naivety on slums. “The United Kingdom’s Department for International Development (DfID) recently completed a major review of its funding of multilateral aid agencies, which tried to identify which of 43 agencies represent the best “value for money” for the UK taxpayer… One outcome is that it has retracted all voluntary funding from UN-HABITAT, the United Nations’ lead agency on urban development issues…” Read more from the Global Urbanist.

Finally we want to wish all urbanist a Belated World Water Day (22 March 2011) with a glimpse of National Geographic’s profile of Water Savvy Cities.  On their list: Tokyo, Las Vegas, Melbourne, New York, Tiajin, Singapore, Kampala, Stockholm and Seattle. See the whole gallery of photos that is part of a National Geographic News series on global water issues.

Public Service Murals in China’s Cities

Public service messages are not always thought of as art.  However, Urban Photo has found some beautiful mural and mosaic PSA’s in the back allies of a Shanghai and Suzhou.  The messages that accompany these colorful displays generally provide “Party-like slogans” that,

…reminded the lane’s former residents of behaviors that went along with a civilized society: protecting the environment (绿化美化,保护环境), maintaining neighborly and familial harmony (邻里团结,家庭和睦) (with the classic two grandparents-two parents-one child family structure), keeping law and order (遵纪守法,遵纪秩序), helping others (in the footsteps of the exemplary revolutionary hero Lei Feng, 学习雷锋,助人为乐)  and promoting the belief in science to combat superstitions (普及科学破除迷).


Murals in Shanghai’s back allies from Urban Photo

Urban Photo’s stories reminded me of a few posters I noticed this summer in a traditional neighborhood in Shanghai.  These posters used cartoons to inform residents of “proper behavior” while foreigners were in Shanghai for the Expo. They were part of a larger campaign that urged Shanghai’s residents not to spit, wear pajamas in public and to generally avoid being rude to tourist.

Sadly though these lanes of traditional low density housing, where such public service art is displayed, are quickly disappearing.  As Urban Photo pointed out Ruihua Lane in Shanghai is scheduled to be demolished in the near future. This leads me to wonder how many other Chinese cities have hidden public service art in their historic allies?

- Melissa

Urban Form in Shanghai vs New York

Berlin

New York

Istanbul

After last week’s post Comparing Urban Form and then seeing these amazing comparative maps by French artist Armelle Caron I was inspired to investigate urban form a little deeper.  One description of Caron’s work says,

Caron strips cities of their spatial context. Roads and rivers become irrelevant, districts and parks disappear. The relationship between built-up areas and empty spaces is obliterated. The city is hung out to dry by its smallest constituent parts. The cartographic compact – maps, however imperfect and partial on paper, are reliable real-world guides – is nullified. The city is un-mapped.

As a New Yorker that spends a large portion of my time studying Asian cities, and traveling to them whenever the opportunity arises, I am always curious as to why some of my favorite artistic interpretations of comparative urban form never seem to compare Asian cities with western cities.  This stark contrast based on shear size of Asian cities compared with Western cities seems an exciting enough reason to further explore their urban patterns. So I decided to use Open Street Maps and some basic Photoshops skills to compare city blocks in Shanghai’s Pudong district (on the eastern side of the river) with lower Manhattan, since both serve as financial districts. Of course my maps are not as in depth of a study as Caron’s deconstructed cities but you can still notice a striking difference between Shanghai’s massive new development in Pudong (east portion) with the Bund and other historic development in Pu Xi (west portions).  Even more striking though is that even the blocks of Pu Xi seems large compared to lower Manhattan.

Shanghai

Manhattan

After walking the massive blocks of Pudong this summer I was not that surprised when I realize that one block in Pudong was the same size as about 6 blocks in Lower Manhattan.  What is surprising though is to consider what the size of these city blocks may mean about the density of these cities if future development mirrored these sections.

Melissa

Urbanization News Roundup Feb 25

More Low-Down on Tall Buildings “There is a growing body of research on the benefits and drawbacks of tall buildings, and this research gives a decidedly mixed picture. Indeed there are significant negative ecological impacts of tall buildings, as well as other negative factors, and the ecological benefits are not as great as is often assumed. ” Read a longer summary of this research here.

Rio Plans for a massive port renovation for the World Cup and Olympics “The Brazilian city Rio’s government has began in February an eight billion reais (4.8 billion U.S. dollars) renovation effort in its port district to prepare the city for the 2014 FIFA World Cup and the 2016 Olympic Games.”

Highway in India Offers Solution to Land Fights “When the state of Uttar Pradesh announced plans to confiscate farmland for a toll road to the Taj Mahal, a grimly predictable plotline ensued. Protesting farmers, angry over low compensation, blocked road work. Frustration boiled into fatal clashes with the police. Then opposition politicians arrived to pillory the state government and pose for photos with farmers. Next, though, came something less predictable. Rather than the usual standoff, the state’s chief minister increased payments to farmers and offered them annuities for the next three decades….”

Population Control in Beijing: Air-raid warnings – As the leaders see it, a plague of human rats in the capital “They do not say so openly, but Beijing’s leaders are busy erecting new barriers to entry for unskilled workers. In December plans were revealed to close down the shelter dwellings within a year. Officials also made it clear that basement accommodation would go too. The local media say the measures could affect more than 1m people.”

Tel-Aviv’s New Master Plan Kept Secret from Residents “The Mayor of Tel-Aviv has called the new Master Plan a ‘constitution for the city,’ yet local officials have stated they will not comment on the plan until after it is approved by the city council. According to a story by Jesse Fox on SustainableCityBlog.com, even Googling the master plan will result in almost no information.”

Construction & Deconstruction of the Shanghai Expo

Between 2004 to 2010 the government of Shanghai relocated over 18,000 households from the 528 hectare site of the 2010 World Expo.  This of course resulted in massive demolition projects and subsequent construction of new housing projects in more remote parts of the city. Last summer I had the opportunity to visit the Expo as part of an NYU course abroad.  For this course I choose to research how the government of Shanghai relocated the 18,000 households.  So when I came across Bricoleurbanism’s post on the (de)constructing the Expo I was very excited to see a satellite image comparisons of the site in 2004 and 2010.  If you look closely below you will notice a compact village in the southeast portion of the site in 2004.

2004 The future site of the 2010 World Expo

2010 World Expo Park Constructed

Of course this post led me to further wonder what was happening with the Expo site today, since the Expo closing ceremony in October?   It was hard to image that this massive event, costing over US$ 40 billion, was constructed to only last six months.  From my trip this summer I already knew that the China Pavilion was intended to be a permanent structure while the other countries’ pavilions would be torn down to make way a park and other land use.  I found some interesting pictures of the rest of the Expo between October to December 2010, as it has turn into a massive demolition site.  By now most of the pavilions are probably completely gone suggests a few bloggers, but I have yet to find more recent images. In the coming months it will be interesting to see how Shanghai decides to reuse this prime land.  Below are a few photos of the demolition from various bloggers.

“Why do they need to construct something before they start demolishing?” I asked. “It’s China,” said my friend, who’s Chinese. “If they’re building a wall, it’s to hide something behind it.”

Constructing a wall to divide the permanent portion of the Expo from the demolition site. Image and quote from: Shanghai Skiok!

 

 

The deconstructed UK Pavilion as of December 2010. Image from Shanghai Scrap.

Read a first hand account of the demolition site from Shanghai Skiok! and see more pictures from CNNGo.

Melissa

Comparing Urban Form

Have you ever wondered how New York City’s urban form compares to London?  Or the ancient streets of Rome?  This comparison from Bricoleurbanism compares eight famous cities’ urban form at the same scale to the city of Mississauga, ON, revealing “the inherent problems of scale in trying to evolve any suburban, auto-oriented area into a more pedestrian-oriented center.”

I would be fascinated to see a similar comparison of these cities with Asian Megacities.  Until then I will just have to share this comparison of urban density in Johannesburg, London, New York and Shanghai from The Endless City.

Melissa